Skip to content

QuillBot prompt generator alternative, compared fairly

The QuillBot prompt generator is a free beta tool with one text box. You type an idea, and it suggests a detailed, structured prompt. Promptcairn is also free, but it asks one question at a time and scores the prompt out of 100. So pick QuillBot for one click speed and Promptcairn for control.

By The Promptcairn team (Product and testing). Last updated .

Side by side

QuillBot prompt generator alternative, compared fairly
QuillBotPromptcairn
PricePage is titled as free; Premium for the wider suite shows $4.17 a month, billed annuallyBuilder and idea generators are free; the enhancer, screenshot and URL tools have a daily free limit
Free limit on the prompt toolNot listed on their siteNone on the builder and the idea generators
Account neededNot listed on their siteNo, for the free parts
What you enterOne text box for your ideaOne idea, then one short question at a time
Who writes the promptTheir generator; the model is not listed on their siteFixed rules in your browser; no model
ScoreNot listed on their siteOut of 100, from fixed weights, with a pass mark at 70
OutputA detailed, structured prompt to paste into your AI toolMarkdown headings for ChatGPT, XML tags for Claude
Image and video promptsNot listed on their siteYes, with aspect ratios and Midjourney parameters
Idea generatorsNot listed on their siteSix kinds: art, drawing, story, fanfic, writing and random
QuillBot prompt generator alternative: a Promptcairn prompt scored 74 out of 100
A real run of our builder: one idea plus three answers, scored 74 out of 100.

What the QuillBot prompt generator does well

First, it is quick. Their page shows one text box and a Generate button. You enter a goal or a task, and the tool returns a detailed prompt. After that, you paste it into your AI tool and adjust it.

It also sits inside a large writing suite. For example, the same site offers a paraphraser, a grammar checker and a summarizer. In addition, QuillBot lists a Chrome extension, desktop apps and a Word add-in, so your other writing tools stay close.

Their advice is sound too. The page tells you to draft a specific request and then follow up until you like the result. We agree with both tips.

Where Promptcairn differs from the QuillBot prompt generator

Promptcairn works the other way around. Instead of writing the prompt for you, it asks one short question at a time. For instance, it asks who the reader is and what format you want. Each answer becomes one line of the prompt.

Next, every answer adds fixed points to a score out of 100. As a result, you can see which part is still missing. No model writes the text, so the same answers always give the same prompt. Because the builder runs in your browser, your idea is not sent to our server.

The output also changes with the target. For ChatGPT, you get Markdown headings. For Claude, the same blocks arrive as XML tags. In addition, there are image and video prompts and six idea generators.

When QuillBot is the better pick

Choose QuillBot if you want a model to write the whole prompt in one click. In that case, a question and answer builder will feel slow. It is also the natural choice if you already pay for their Premium plan and work in their apps every day.

However, some details are not public. Their page does not list a free limit for this tool, the model behind it, or whether you need an account. The tool also carries a Beta label, so it may change.

On the other hand, pick Promptcairn if you want to see why a prompt is strong or weak. Both tools cost nothing to try, so run the same idea through each and keep the result you prefer.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

Is the QuillBot prompt generator free?

Their page calls it a free AI prompt generator. However, it does not list a usage limit for this tool, so we cannot confirm one.

Do I need an account for the QuillBot prompt generator?

Their page does not say. In contrast, Promptcairn needs no account for the builder or the idea generators.

Which model writes the prompt on QuillBot?

It is not listed on their site. Promptcairn uses no model for the builder, because fixed rules turn your answers into the prompt.

Is there a free alternative that scores my prompt?

Yes. Promptcairn gives every prompt a score out of 100 from fixed weights. For example, the task is worth 18 points and the audience 16.

Can either tool make prompts for images or video?

Promptcairn has image and video targets with their own questions. In contrast, QuillBot lists no image or video modes on its prompt page, although the site has its own AI image generator.

Sources and references